Perfect Party Sandwiches are an easy and delicious addition to your next party. Or maybe you’ve been invited to a potluck or a party and asked to bring something. What on earth should you make?
Let me suggest these super easy and incredibly delicious Perfect Party Sandwiches! They’re a huge crowd pleaser and the best part? You can customize the recipe any way you like. Warm and savory with melted cheese and crispy onions…they will win your guests over, guaranteed.
Kids LOVE these so consider making a batch to freeze (don’t add the onions till you bake them) and bake ’em up when you need a fast, easy meal.
See Kate’s Tips below for Perfect Party Sandwich combo ideas.
Perfect Party Sandwiches
These sandwiches will be gobbled up at your next party or potluck, I guarantee it! They're easy to make and you can customize the ingredients however you like!
Ingredients
- 24 rolls biscuits, or ciabatta bread
- 1 pound deli meat of your choice turkey, ham, or roast beef will all work well
- 1 pound provolone cheese or cheese of your choice
- 1 cup mayonnaise
- ½ cup Dijon mustard
- 1 cup sweet pickles
- 1 ½ cups crispy onions
- 1 stick of melted butter to brush on top
Instructions
- Cut rolls in half.
- Mix the mayo and mustard together. Spread each half with the mayonnaise and mustard mixture.
- Put a half slice of meat on one half of each roll.
- Put 2-3 pickles on top of the meat.
- Put one slice of cheese on top of the pickles, cut the slice of cheese to fit the roll.
- Sprinkle on the onions, about ½ tablespoon on each sandwich.
- Put both halves together and brush the tops with melted butter.
- Bake at 350 for 15-20 minutes or until cheese melts and the tops are a little crispy.
- Expect everyone to rave!!
Use any combo of meat and cheese, or, for example, go vegetarian and use avocado, veggies, and cheese. So easy, so delish!
These Easy Chicken Sliders are great for a party, too!
Why I love Perfect Party Sandwiches:
- They are easy to make
- Everyone loves them
- You can customize them however you like
- Kids love them
Kate’s Tips for perfect Perfect Party Sandwiches
- Try ham and cheddar, turkey and Swiss, or roast beef and provolone. Ham and pineapple, or turkey/bacon/avocado. Feel free to use any combo you like!
- I buy the French Hamburger Rolls from Publix. They work really well and have a little more heft to them than most dinner rolls.
- Try biscuits or ciabatta bread for a slightly different twist. The pic below shows ciabatta rolls.
- If you have it on hand, onion jam would be a delicious substitute for the crispy onions.
- If you’re prepping these in advance, don’t add the crispy onions. Lay the sandwiches out on sheet pans, cover them with plastic wrap, and refrigerate until you’re ready to heat them. Add the onions before you put them in the oven so they don’t get soggy.
- During the holidays, turkey and cranberry sauce with Swiss cheese and the crispy onions would be amazing!
- Add crisp bacon to take these over the top.
- If you want to keep it vegetarian, try avocado, veggies, arugula, and cheese.
- Kick up the heat and use pepper-jack cheese and pickled jalapenos instead of sweet pickles.
- When you serve these at your holiday party, I guarantee they’ll be the hit of the night!
- I use these Crispy Onions.
- This is the mayonnaise I use…and the Dijon mustard.
- These organic bread and butter pickles are great.
- Try adding a teaspoon or so of Worcestershire sauce to the mayo/mustard mixture.
- Feel free to add sliced banana peppers or a thin slice of a ripe tomato. Try whatever you like!
- Roast pork and melty cheese would be great, and meatballs and some sauce and mozzarella would be over-the-top amazing 🙂
- If your grocery store has gluten-free buns, try those!
Holding on to Hope